From the Office of Public Affairs | http://www.news.ku.edu
Headlines
SEC could patch enforcement mechanism, regardless of Supreme Court ruling, analysis shows
LAWRENCE — In November 2023, the Supreme Court heard a case about how the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission prosecutes those accused of financial wrongdoing. SEC v. Jarkesy has some fearing it will end the agency’s ability to pursue bad financial actors, while others say it will finally end the agency’s overreach. A new analysis from a University of Kansas legal expert finds neither outcome is likely from the high court’s pending decision — and there is a simple patch to apply for the future.
Hall Center announces 2023 Byron Caldwell Smith Book Awards
LAWRENCE — The Hall Center for the Humanities at the University of Kansas has announced the winners of the 2023 Byron Caldwell Smith Book Awards, given biennially to individuals who live or are employed in Kansas and who have written outstanding books published in the previous two years. Charles Forrest Jones won the fiction award for “The Illusion of Simple,” a mystery novel set in a western Kansas county in the 1980s. Ben Chappell received the nonfiction award for his book “Mexican American Fastpitch: Identity at Play in Vernacular Sport.”
Full stories below.
————————————————————————
Contact: Mike Krings, KU News Service, 785-864-8860, [email protected], @MikeKrings
SEC could patch enforcement mechanism, regardless of Supreme Court ruling, analysis shows
LAWRENCE — The Supreme Court recently heard a case about how the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission prosecutes those accused of financial wrongdoing. The case has some fearing it will end the agency’s ability to pursue bad financial actors, while others say it will finally end the agency’s overreach.
A new study from a University of Kansas legal expert analyzes the arguments and prosecutions the agency has made in recent years, arguing it is likely neither — and there is a simple patch to apply for the future.
In November 2023, the court heard SEC v. Jarkesy, a case in which the former prosecuted the latter in one its administrative courts for alleged wrongdoing in the way Jarkesy managed hedge funds. The SEC has regularly prosecuted people in its own courts, in which cases are heard by a judge appointed by the agency, without a jury. Jarkesy argued that was illegal, and the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in his favor, stating such prosecutions should happen in federal courts.
The Supreme Court decision is pending, but Alexander Platt, associate professor of law at KU, analyzed two years’ worth of similar actions by the SEC for his article, forthcoming in the Notre Dame Law Review Reflection and available on SSRN.
“That opinion evinced a lot of shock waves in the world of securities enforcement,” Platt said of the 5th circuit ruling. “It didn’t surprise anyone the Supreme Court took the case. It wasn’t about whether Jarkesy was guilty or innocent. The 5th Circuit said the Constitution doesn’t allow the SEC to bring this enforcement in its own courts.”
The key, Platt writes, is that Jarkesy was unregistered with the SEC. Securities traders who register with the agency get a license to trade, manage funds and perform other functions, but the financial area Jarkesy worked in was not required to be registered. Recent Supreme Court rulings hold that those who register with the SEC in essence agree to have actions taken against them heard in SEC administrative courts, Platt writes.
“It matters, I think, because there is a legal and constitutional argument that folks who register with the SEC might be consenting to appearing in the SEC’s courts,” Platt said. “You’re giving something up in order to do business.”
Further, Platt examined 1,481 actions the SEC brought in its courts from fiscal years 2021 and 2023. He found that only about 5% of the actions were taken against unregistered parties for fraud-related activities seeking monetary penalties. Therefore, should the high court rule against the SEC, little would have to change, he writes. The agency could simply amend its registration forms to include language that those who register agree to have cases against them heard in the SEC’s courts, while unregistered parties could proceed in federal court.
The paper cites media reports and arguments from legal experts speculating about the ramifications the decision would have, regardless of how the high court rules. Some express concern a ruling against the agency will gut its ability to pursue fraudsters and financial wrongdoers.
“The SEC saw the ruling from the 5th Circuit and said, ‘Oh no, that’s not good for us, because we pursue these actions in our courts all the time,’” Platt said.
Other parties have viewed the case a chance to rid the agency of powers of overreach and a further strike against the administrative state.
The true effect will likely be somewhere in the middle, Platt said, as the numbers show the SEC has pursued action against few unregistered parties. Limiting actions in its administrative courts to registered financial actors could effectively patch any hole the Supreme Court may be about to rip in the agency’s enforcement mechanism.
-30-
————————————————————————
Don’t miss new episodes of “When Experts Attack!,”
a KU News Service podcast hosted by Kansas Public Radio.
https://kansaspublicradio.org/podcast/when-experts-attack
————————————————————————
Contact: Dan Oetting, Hall Center for the Humanities, [email protected], @KUHallCenter
Hall Center announces 2023 Byron Caldwell Smith Book Awards
LAWRENCE — The Hall Center for the Humanities at the University of Kansas has announced the winners of the 2023 Byron Caldwell Smith Book Awards.
Charles Forrest Jones won the fiction award for “The Illusion of Simple,” a mystery novel set in a western Kansas county in the 1980s.
Ben Chappell received the nonfiction award for his book “Mexican American Fastpitch: Identity at Play in Vernacular Sport.”
Jones is the retired director of KU’s Public Management Center and was a courtesy associate professor in the School of Public Affairs & Administration.
Described by one reviewer as “an unflinchingly intimate epic,” the book follows the efforts of a pugnacious sheriff to solve a murder by sifting through not-so-simple politics, racism and loyalties of small-town Kansas.
The book was published by the University of Iowa Press in 2022.
Published in 2021 by Stanford University Press, Chappell’s ethnography of Mexican American fastpitch explores the cultural significance and enduring legacy of fastpitch softball within the Mexican American community.
Chappell, professor of American studies, uses research and storytelling to trace the sport’s roots from its origins in the early 20th century to its flourishing presence in Mexican American neighborhoods across the United States.
The Byron Caldwell Smith Book Awards were established at the bequest of Kate Stephens, a former KU student and one of KU’s first women professors.
As an undergraduate in the 1870s, Stephens learned to love the study of Greek language and literature from Professor Byron Caldwell Smith. In his name, she established this award, given biennially to individuals who live or are employed in Kansas and who have written outstanding books published in the previous two years.
The next application cycle will be in spring 2025.
-30-
————————————————————————
KU News Service
1450 Jayhawk Blvd.
Lawrence KS 66045
Phone: 785-864-3256
Fax: 785-864-3339
http://www.news.ku.edu
Erinn Barcomb-Peterson, director of news and media relations, [email protected]
Today’s News is a free service from the Office of Public Affairs
